Every month I attempt to remember to join in with other bloggers posting up book reviews. It also helps me to remember to keep making time to read: if you want to write then reading is essential!
The Island, Victoria Hislop, Headline Book Publishing
This book was given to me by a friend who had
inadvertently ended up with two copies. It came with a shrug. I soon picked up
why. The story is well researched, well intentioned, the writing isn't what I
would identify as bad, exactly. I feel like a heel for pointing this out,
actually, because a story with a kind heart is a good thing: but there is far
too much tell and not enough show. I like to work things out for myself. Show
me a scene, I'll know if people are happy or sad or complicated. I'd rather
make up my own mind, it makes me more involved, and the further into the story
I go the more this applies. For example, if on page 206 I need to be told that
a key protagonist 'was a mistress of restraint… In this way she kept up the
appearance of being contented' maybe the writer doesn't think I have bothered
to notice this character trait? Is that a lack of confidence in the writer or
the reader? One feels slighted! Still, it was a debut novel. I hope a stronger
editor or some honest friends will help shake the annoyances out. I didn't regret
reading it.
Go here for more January book reviews or to sign up to be a reviewer for February:
Comments
Good review. Thanks!
Author of Wilder Mage at Spirit Called
Facebook Wilder Mage
So, in other words, telling is more forgivable at the beginning? You've given me something to think about!
I confess I used to explain a lot in my writing (and still have this tendency to tell the reader: "Did you get it? Did you?") But fortunately, I have great CPs who always point this out to me. :)
Yep CD, readers need some thought space!
Yolanda, it was in the spirit of fair play and curiosity.
Lorena, this is a personal thing obviously but it is how it works for me. I like best a scene that is realistic, in the world of the book, but relevant to the plot/character development: as though someone had simply edited a life. I found reading scripts and plays a good way to learn this. And if you do need to absolutely idiot proof how your reader thinks of a character, yes, do it at the beginning :-)
That soooo describes my Coffeehouse endeavors....and I see The Squid almost daily!
Are you one to abandon books or do you plug along until the end?
Hello MOCK! Attempting to remember is something I do a lot :-) I try to give a book the best chance: but there is a point at which I think I can gain nothing but annoyance from this. Once I was so offended by a writer's sexism that I threw the book on a fire. It wasn't my book but it felt like the right thing to do.
I know what you mean about feeling a bit mean though, but honesty is best I think!
Stephanie, you make a good point. **huffs**
mshatch, thank you, because even when huffy one does like to be kindly :-)